Abominations of the silver screen
by chuckofish
We blog about movies quite frequently and almost exclusively about ones we love. But what about the ones that make our blood boil? What about the monstrous creations that should never, never have been allowed to see the light of day?
Take for example the upcoming 47 Ronin starring the hapless Keanu Reeves (does he ever make good movies?):
The 47 Ronin, as you know, is probably the most famous story in Japan, where it amounts to a national epic. A true story of profound samurai loyalty. In Japan it has received countless film and TV adaptations, of which the 1941 version is best known. I can’t imagine why, but none of them involves a Japanese/American, witches, dragons, and other monsters. The true story should be graceful and mannered to the point of being (to a westerner) almost excruciatingly slow-moving. The tension mounts, you follow the story in what seems like real time as the ronin wait years to avenge their master:
The Keanu Reeves version is just heresy and probably a terrible movie to boot. I feel the same way about 300 and the upcoming 300: Rise of an Empire
which couldn’t be worse if it tried. Honestly, if people want to make comic book adventures, why pick on history? The real story the battle of Salamis is infinitely cooler and so very Greek (that Themistocles is one crafty guy). Really, go read about it in Herodotus sometime.
I also have to add to this list the many terrible movie versions of Beowulf, which is a fabulous poem that deserves better. If you haven’t read it lately, revisit the beautiful Seamus Heaney translation (R.I.P., Seamus), but don’t ever watch these movies.
I mean, really, Angelina Joli as Grendel’s mother? Some scaly monster. The Gerard Butler movie is pretty — I think it was filmed in Iceland, but it was a terrible mess and ultimately had little to do with Beowulf. Why can’t Gerard Butler make a decent movie anymore?
Last, but not least, I leave you with one of the all-time worst adaptations of a classic story. Troy.
There is so much wrong with this movie that just contemplating the errors exhausts me beyond reason. I can’t list them here so you’ll just have to trust me. Whatever you do, don’t waste your precious life watching it.
Sadly, there are more bad movies out there than great ones, but the worst offenders are the ones that take some iconic story and mutilate it beyond recognition. What would you add to the never-watch list?










































